For Reviewers
Journal of AI Ethics and Legal uses double-anonymous peer review. Every research article published by the journal must first be assessed by at least two independent external reviewers with relevant subject expertise. Author and reviewer identities are not disclosed to one another during peer review. Independent reviewers assess originality, validity and significance to help editors make the publication decision.
The reviewers play a key role of in ensuring the integrity of the scholarly record. Every reviewer is vital and bears a great responsibility and is expected to perform manuscript evaluation in a timely, transparent, and ethical manner, following the COPE guidelines https://publicationethics.org/files/cope-ethical-guidelines-peer-reviewers-v2_0.pdf.
Journal of AI Ethics and Legal looks to reviewers to help us ensure the following in a submitted paper
- Demonstration of novel theoretical frameworks or significant normative contributions in subfields such as algorithmic fairness, responsible AI governance, ethical AI design, or emerging regulatory paradigms, with clear articulation of their societal implications and pathways to practical adoption;
- Cross-disciplinary relevance that stimulates discourse across domains (e.g., law, computer science, philosophy, social sciences) and provides actionable insights for both academic researchers, policymakers, and industry practitioners.
- The data reproducibility;
- Soundness of conclusions.
Reviewers' Responsibilities
- Have the necessary expertise to judge the scientific quality of the manuscript;
- Provide quality review reports with considerate and useful comments;
- Remain responsive throughout the peer review process;
- Maintain standards of professionalism and ethics.
Reviewers' Benefits
- The reviewers receive a personalized reviewer certificate and eligible to be considered for the “Outstanding Reviewer Awards”.
- A number of excellent reviewers have the chance to be promoted to Reviewer Board Members through the approval by the Editor(s)-in-Chief.
- Reviewers may create a profile on Publons and have their reviewing activity automatically added for participating journals. Profiles on Publons can also be integrated with ORCID.
Call for Applications: Reviewer Board Member
Journal of AI Ethics and Legal assembles the Reviewer Board which has the excellent reviewers inside to improve the quality and speed of peer review process of the papers. Excellent reviewers must be considered as experienced researchers who make the contribution in reviewing manuscripts regularly and providing rigorous and high-quality review reports for manuscripts.
Members have an initial term of one year, with the option to extend for another term or terminated. The responsibilities and benefits for members are the same as those for regular reviewers, with the following additions:
- Reviewer Board members must review a minimum of one manuscripts per year. Members are required to recommend potential reviewers when they are unable to provide a report;
- Reviewer Board certificates will be provided by the journal.
In the future, every member has the priority consideration to enroll into the Editorial Board based on the comprehensive evaluation.
How to apply?
To become a member of this program, please apply to email:editorialoffice@masonpublish.org The editorial office of Journal of AI Ethics and Legal will be notified. Applications will be reviewed by the Editors and Editorial Board. The office will send you the email to inform the result of your application.