Publication Ethics and Malpractice
Modern Law Research is committed to the highest standards of publication ethics. This statement is aligned with the Core Practices and guidance of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) (https://publicationethics.org).
Duties of editors
Editors:
- evaluate manuscripts solely on their scholarly merit — originality, rigour, relevance to the journal's aims and scope — without regard to the authors' race, gender, nationality, religion, political views or institutional affiliation;
- are responsible for the decision to accept or reject a manuscript and are guided by the journal's policies and by legal requirements concerning libel, copyright and plagiarism;
- keep manuscripts and all information about them confidential, and disclose them only to those who need to know (reviewers, the editorial team, the publisher);
- do not use unpublished material from a submitted manuscript in their own research without the authors' written consent;
- do not handle manuscripts they have written themselves, or manuscripts written by family members or colleagues, or relating to products or services in which they have an interest. Such submissions are handled independently of the editor concerned and that editor's research group;
- declare any competing interests and withdraw from the handling of a manuscript when a conflict exists;
- act promptly when ethical concerns about a submitted or published article are raised, following the procedures below.
Duties of reviewers
Reviewers:
- assess manuscripts objectively, with constructive and courteous comments;
- keep the manuscript confidential and do not share it or use its content before publication;
- decline to review when they have a conflict of interest, or when they cannot provide a timely and competent review;
- point out relevant published work that is not cited, and tell the editor if they suspect plagiarism, duplicate publication, fabrication or other misconduct;
- remember that the journal uses double-anonymous peer review: reviewers must not try to identify the authors, and their own identities are concealed from authors.
Duties of authors
Authors:
- submit original work that has not been published previously (except as a preprint, abstract, published lecture, academic thesis or registered report) and is not under consideration elsewhere;
- cite and quote all sources properly and obtain permission for reuse of third-party material; submitted manuscripts are screened for similarity (see the Plagiarism and Similarity Screening Policy);
- report data and methods honestly and completely. Fabrication, falsification, image manipulation and selective reporting are unacceptable;
- list as authors only those who have made substantial contributions, and ensure that all authors have approved the submitted version and are accountable for the work (see the authorship criteria in the Guidelines for Authors);
- disclose all financial and personal relationships that could be seen to influence the work, and all funding sources;
- declare any use of generative AI in the writing process, as required in the Guidelines for Authors. AI tools cannot be listed as authors;
- promptly notify the editors if they discover a significant error or inaccuracy in their published work and cooperate in publishing a correction or retraction when needed.
Handling suspected misconduct
Misconduct includes, among other things, plagiarism, duplicate or redundant publication, fabrication or falsification of data, image manipulation, undisclosed conflicts of interest, authorship manipulation, and manipulation of the peer-review process.
Anyone may report concerns, in confidence, to editorialoffice@masonpublish.org with as much evidence as possible.
- The editorial office acknowledges the report and the Editor-in-Chief decides whether it warrants investigation. Reports are treated confidentially, and the identity of the person who raised concerns is not revealed without need.
- The editors gather the relevant evidence and give the authors (and, where relevant, reviewers or editors) an opportunity to respond.
- Where appropriate, the editors may seek advice from independent experts or from the authors' institution or funder.
- The editors decide on the outcome, which may include: no action; a request for clarification or revision; a correction; an expression of concern; retraction of the article; rejection of a manuscript under review; a notification to the authors' institution or funder; and a ban on future submissions.
- The outcome is recorded and the people involved are informed.
Corrections
If a published article contains an error that does not invalidate its findings (for example an author-list error, a mistake in a figure or table, or an incorrect statement of funding), the journal publishes a correction notice (corrigendum or erratum) that is linked to the original article. The journal may also correct the article itself, with a clear notice describing the change and the date, so that the version history is transparent. Minor typographical errors that do not affect the meaning may be fixed with a note in the version history. Changes to authorship after submission follow the policy in the Guidelines for Authors, and approved changes to published articles result in a corrigendum.
Expressions of concern
The journal may publish an expression of concern about a published article when there is credible evidence of possible misconduct or serious error, and the investigation is not yet finished or is inconclusive, or when the institution does not conduct an adequate investigation. The notice is linked to the original article and is updated or replaced when the investigation ends.
Retractions
The journal retracts an article when its findings are unreliable as a result of misconduct (for example fabrication or falsification) or honest error, when it is a redundant or duplicate publication, when it is plagiarism, when it reports unethical research, or when unauthorised authorship changes have been made. Retractions follow the COPE Retraction Guidelines:
- A retraction notice, linked to the original article, is published and states the reason for retraction and who is retracting it. It is freely available.
- The original article remains available on the journal website, clearly marked "Retracted" (on the article page and on the PDF), so that the scholarly record is preserved. In exceptional cases, such as legal reasons or a risk to public health, the article's content may be removed, with a notice explaining why.
- Indexing services and, where the article has one, its DOI metadata are updated to show the retraction.
Appeals and complaints
Appeals against editorial decisions. Authors who wish to appeal a decision on their manuscript may submit a formal appeal request to the Editor-in-Chief, with a clear explanation of the grounds. Only one appeal per submission is considered, and the appeal decision is final. (This follows the Guidelines for Authors.)
Complaints. Complaints about editorial processes, the conduct of editors or reviewers, or the journal's services can be sent to editorialoffice@masonpublish.org.
Complainants are asked to provide the manuscript or article details and a clear description of their concern.
Publication fees and editorial independence
The article processing charge (USD 400 per accepted article) is payable only after acceptance and plays no part in editorial decisions. Waiver requests are assessed by publisher staff who do not take part in the editorial decision, and neither the request nor its outcome affects peer review or acceptance (see the Open access policy).